I am an ametuer poet and love this poem. The form simulating the drip. But personally (and from a different pond of course) i would have the water landing on something soft, such as a leaf, wet grass, or flower. But that, as you say is what makes us different. I also come from a place where i believe we are all special. Yes yes including you, but i have a feeling this thought would provoke a roll of the eyes or some such display. Me too at a time, i used to joke, and still do in certain moods, that from all of the semen that i have wasted down the drain i probably have a million rat babies in the sewer looking for a father. But the drain is such a final place for all of this feeling and emotion to go. it seem that maybe were you in a cheerier or more hopeful mood it would go somewhere else. you could even continue this at viii in the sewer, going to the water treatment facility, passing the rats and garbage, mixing with rain water and soiled leaves. eventually becoming clean and joining a river or waterfall. i am suprised by the ammount that the symbolism of the drain bring out in me. i don't know exactly why i rated as i did. the vision is only a four because of the sour note at the end, but maybe should be higher, now experiencing all the thought that it provokes. origionality and technique could probably go a little higher as well but i'm sticking with my original rating. it's still great work though, i hope some of my thoughts help you come up with some new ideas, because i know you have given me some. thank you for sharing.
Disclaimer I don't like rating what I'm critiquing, it seems contrary to the point, so I gave you an even 5 stars, but that's nothing to base my thoughts off of.
Congratulations my friend! This was well-deserved. I remember this poem from the last poll. Glad to see your work getting recognition. When I saw the title in the footer, my face lit up because I knew 'that's Liedy.' Anyways, hope that doesn't sound too creepy. On to your questions:
Is it too long?
No, not at all, the only thing that makes it seem long is the height, which is created by the short lines, which are read quite easily and flow well, but upon first reading it a week ago, it was definitely not what I would consider a long poem.
Does the line break help portraying the narrators state of mind?
Yes, upon reading that question my mind thought of two different part parts of the poem. This one:
Maybe I'm a teardrop.
or one of urine.
I feel that this truly shows just how much the narrator's mind is wandering, both in context from the contrast from urine to a teardrop, and the line break in between which creates a short pause. Also, the phrasing in those 3 lines is spot on, it was a good move to make the sentence "Maybe I'm a teardrop" its own line without separating words, because then the idea is whole, whereas with the next sentence it is separated, and we are given the impression that the narrator believes one and not the other. The other part I thought of was:
I don't mind, but I've never really liked those girls.
I don't really like girls at all.
I like sex though, so.. I let them.
Again, great choices in where to break your lines and stanzas to isolate, empower and emphasize ideas. It really comes across as narration of someone's thoughts.
Is breaking it of in parts useful for flow and effect?
It's useful for effect, for separating the different thoughts in an organized way and then dovetailing them together. I think in the end that it also benefits the flow as well, but more importantly it keeps the ideas separate until it is time for them to be combined. Parts are generally used more in narrative poetry, but also for what you have done here. There are also some other uses, which I cannot think of at the moment.
Some Thoughts
I really like the last 4 lines, but some lines before it, the phrasing of it sounds very cliche:
We might be of different water and
we might not drip alike
I've heard variations of this a lot, it doesn't seem to go with the narrator's voice as much as the rest of the poem, and I can't help but feel this could be phrased better so that it fits in with the rest of the poem and sounds more like the narrator we heard in the previous parts.
Other than that I've always enjoyed reading your work!
This gets better and better. I was writing something myself, and then remembered this and realized how true this is. It is almost.. disgustingly true; "and even though I sometimes seduce you and sometimes want to beat you up
I don't really like you at all.
I'd like to be you though.
Perhaps.. that is why
(plip.)
we sometimes fall
(plop.)
in love."
.. yes.. disgustingly true. It gives me creeps, or something like it, but I love this poem, it is... I think I've made that clear already Lovely work.
I think it's just about right length wise, if it were longer it would be too long, and if it were shorter it wouldn't feel like enough. I like the structure, especially because of the drops metaphor, maybe you didn't do it on purpose but it makes you feel like the poem is falling. It's nice. I'm not sure if it's necessary, but it was a nice way of finishing the poem.
No. I think vii detracts. It's message - the commonality of mortality - is enough said. Hemmingway for instance to paraphrase: "All live and die, it's only the details of one's life that differentiates one from another."
The rest of the poem has some fine points, though.
I'm glad you think so. It is a love poem, although I admit it is ambiguous, the drain symbolizes love which I wanted to sidestep with death. I'm pretty sure most didn't read it like that though.
Congratulations my friend! This was well-deserved. I remember this poem from the last poll. Glad to see your work getting recognition. When I saw the title in the footer, my face lit up because I knew 'that's Liedy.'
Is it too long?
No, not at all, the only thing that makes it seem long is the height, which is created by the short lines, which are read quite easily and flow well, but upon first reading it a week ago, it was definitely not what I would consider a long poem.
Does the line break help portraying the narrators state of mind?
Yes, upon reading that question my mind thought of two different part parts of the poem. This one:
Maybe I'm a teardrop.
or one of
urine.
I feel that this truly shows just how much the narrator's mind is wandering, both in context from the contrast from urine to a teardrop, and the line break in between which creates a short pause. Also, the phrasing in those 3 lines is spot on, it was a good move to make the sentence "Maybe I'm a teardrop" its own line without separating words, because then the idea is whole, whereas with the next sentence it is separated, and we are given the impression that the narrator believes one and not the other. The other part I thought of was:
I don't mind, but
I've never really liked those girls.
I don't really like girls at all.
I like sex though, so..
I let them.
Again, great choices in where to break your lines and stanzas to isolate, empower and emphasize ideas. It really comes across as narration of someone's thoughts.
Is breaking it of in parts useful for flow and effect?
It's useful for effect, for separating the different thoughts in an organized way and then dovetailing them together. I think in the end that it also benefits the flow as well, but more importantly it keeps the ideas separate until it is time for them to be combined. Parts are generally used more in narrative poetry, but also for what you have done here. There are also some other uses, which I cannot think of at the moment.
Some Thoughts
I really like the last 4 lines, but some lines before it, the phrasing of it sounds very cliche:
We might be of
different water
and
we might not drip alike
I've heard variations of this a lot, it doesn't seem to go with the narrator's voice as much as the rest of the poem, and I can't help but feel this could be phrased better so that it fits in with the rest of the poem and sounds more like the narrator we heard in the previous parts.
Other than that I've always enjoyed reading your work!
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.